The social networking website called Facebook is a tool to exchange information that has now made its way into the courtroom and is being used as evidence in litigation, particularly in family law disputes. In the United States, Facebook messages are commonly used in family law cases, as well as in civil and criminal cases and jury selection; while in Canada, the use of Facebook as documentary evidence is steadily on the rise.
Facebook has recently simplified its privacy settings and a user can now set his or her Facebook settings to enable only persons the user has manually added to their “friends list” with the ability to access and view the user’s on-line profile.
Another important feature within Facebook’s account privacy settings is the user’s ability to limit the information “friends” can view on the user’s profile. For instance, a user can prevent an ex-spouse or soon to be ex-spouse from viewing photos, relationship status, or wall postings.
Facebook users should be aware of a specific privacy setting that is available for ‘Applications’. Even though some users do not have the game FarmVille, or similar Facebook games uploaded to their profile, when a user’s “friend” has installed the game on their profile that game now has the capability of pulling personal Facebook information and photos from any listed “friends” of that individual. An adjustment to the privacy settings to prevent any sharing of information with an Application is recommended.
Due to the increase in the use of Facebook as documentary evidence in several recent Ontario family law court cases, Facebook users with pending court matters should not post information pertaining to the case and should also consider adjusting their privacy settings to avoid the possibility of having personal information used against them in court.
Custodial and access (also known as “visitation”) rights under a court order or from a separation agreement are enforceable under the Criminal Code of Canada and the Hague Convention on International Child Abduction. Both the Code and the Convention serve to protect a child’s right to security and stability by enforcing custody orders and prohibiting child abductions, locally and internationally.
The enforcement of custodial and access rights in Ontario is also governed by the Children’s Law Reform Act (CLRA). Pursuant to section 36 of the Act, if a family court judge is satisfied that there are “reasonable and probable grounds for believing that a person is unlawfully withholding a child” the court has the ability to compel the police to enforce a custody or access order and may authorize the police to locate, apprehend, and deliver the child to the person entitled to custody or access of that child.
Courts have refused to grant an order for police enforcement on the grounds that it would be intrusive and a potentially frightening method of enforcement to a child. Drake v. Cox (1993). Such a result would not be in the best interests of a child and some courts have instead opted to punish an act of willful contempt by imposing either a fine or imprisonment for the failure to comply with a custodial or access arrangement as stipulated by the court.
Courts can issue police enforcement orders if deemed appropriate in light of the surrounding circumstances, such as a history of unjustified access denial between the parties, serious threats of non-removal of the child, or to maintain the relationship between the child and the person entitled to custody or access, and that such enforcement would outweigh any potential risks.
For more information about the enforcement of your custodial or access arrangement, contact us at 416 222 4555 or info@divorcesupport.ca.
Access (also known as “visitation”) is the child’s right to have contact with his or her non-custodial parent after a separation or divorce. Access can be determined informally between the parents, by way of a written agreement, or a court can make an order.
In addition to a biological parent, other persons who have had or want to have a relationship with a child may also seek reasonable access pursuant to section 21 of the Children’s Law Reform Act and section 16(3) of the Divorce Act. “Non-parents” include grandparents and other relatives, step-parents, and common-law partners who are not the biological parent of the child.
Non-parents must seek leave (permission) from the court to submit an application for access. A court can grant an order for access to a non-parent under a number of circumstances, including where the non-parent has had a close relationship and is seeking to continue to spend time with the child. The merits of an application for access are determined based on whether it would be in the child’s “best interests” and whether there is “some beneficial connection” between the non-parent and the child. J.H. v. B.G. (1993).
As a general rule, biological parents have the right to determine with whom their children will associate. However, a judge can override a parent’s access decision on the premise that the child would benefit from having contact with the non-parent, particularly if there is a genuine bond between the child and the non-parent and whether severing any pre-existing relationship would have an adverse impact upon the child.
An order for access will not be granted if the biological parent can provide compelling reasons that denying access to the non-parent would be in the child’s best interests.
Contact a Family Lawyer who can assist you in understanding the judicial process and your rights and obligations before filing an application for access with the court. Call Niren and Associates Family Law Practice at 416 222 4555 or email us at info@divorcesupport.ca.
Commencing March 1, 2010, the McGuinty government will be implementing major reforms to a variety of Family Law matters in Ontario. The reforms have been introduced with the objective of improving the public’s access to justice in family courts.
The following are some highlights of the changes that will take effect under the new legislation:
Full details of the upcoming reforms are still to be released by the government.
Check back to our blog for further details once the family law changes come into effect on March 1, 2010.
For further information on family law and divorce contact us at info@divorcesupport.ca or call us at 416 222 4555
The Office of the Children’s Lawyer (OCL) is an independent law office within the Ministry of the Attorney General offering services on behalf of children respecting their personal and property rights.
OCL investigates, advocates, protects and represents the personal and property rights and obligations of children in proceedings before the courts and tribunals of Ontario.
In house Toronto staff of lawyers, articling students and clinical investigators carry a personal caseload and supervise members of the OCL panels who do Children’s Lawyer work across the province.
To get the OCL involved in the custody/access proceedings, one or more of the parties may ask the court to make an order appointing the Children’s Lawyer.
The appointment of the Children’s Lawyer may assist the court when it requires independent information and representation about the interests, needs and wishes of the child or children who is subject of the proceedings.
The Children’s Lawyer does not represent children in child support matters in custody/access cases.
For more information about the OLC or child custody or access issues contact us at 416 222 4555 or info@divorcesupport.ca