Custodial and access (also known as “visitation”) rights under a court order or from a separation agreement are enforceable under the Criminal Code of Canada and the Hague Convention on International Child Abduction. Both the Code and the Convention serve to protect a child’s right to security and stability by enforcing custody orders and prohibiting child abductions, locally and internationally.
The enforcement of custodial and access rights in Ontario is also governed by the Children’s Law Reform Act (CLRA). Pursuant to section 36 of the Act, if a family court judge is satisfied that there are “reasonable and probable grounds for believing that a person is unlawfully withholding a child” the court has the ability to compel the police to enforce a custody or access order and may authorize the police to locate, apprehend, and deliver the child to the person entitled to custody or access of that child.
Courts have refused to grant an order for police enforcement on the grounds that it would be intrusive and a potentially frightening method of enforcement to a child. Drake v. Cox (1993). Such a result would not be in the best interests of a child and some courts have instead opted to punish an act of willful contempt by imposing either a fine or imprisonment for the failure to comply with a custodial or access arrangement as stipulated by the court.
Courts can issue police enforcement orders if deemed appropriate in light of the surrounding circumstances, such as a history of unjustified access denial between the parties, serious threats of non-removal of the child, or to maintain the relationship between the child and the person entitled to custody or access, and that such enforcement would outweigh any potential risks.
For more information about the enforcement of your custodial or access arrangement, contact us at 416 222 4555 or info@divorcesupport.ca.